Free Documents
Promissory Note

Consignment Agreement

A consignment agreement is a contract between a consignor (the owner of the goods) and a consignee (a seller or third party) where the consignee agrees to sell the consignor’s goods on their behalf. The consignor retains ownership of the goods until they are sold, at which point the consignee takes a percentage of the sale price as commission. This is common in retail, art galleries and second-hand markets where sellers don’t want to buy inventory outright. But without a well-structured agreement, disputes can arise and cost legal battles and damaged relationships. Understanding the potential pitfalls when drafting a consignment agreement is key to a smooth and profitable partnership.

Ambiguous Terms and Conditions

A well drafted consignment agreement must clearly outline the rights and responsibilities of both parties. If the agreement is vague or incomplete, disputes can arise over payment, ownership and liability. Clear and concise language is key to avoiding misunderstandings and legal action.

For example, if an agreement says the consignee must pay the consignor “within a reasonable time” after selling an item but doesn’t specify a time frame, the consignee can delay payment indefinitely. The consignor, expecting payment on time, could take legal action to recover the funds. This creates unnecessary conflict that could have been avoided with a specific payment schedule.

A simple solution is to specify exact payment terms in the contract. Stating “payment must be made within 10 business days of the sale” leaves no room for interpretation. Outlining penalties for late payment also ensures accountability and reduces potential legal disputes. Payment tracking mechanisms like requiring a sales report should also be in the contract. Having an automated invoicing system or escrow arrangement where payments are processed securely can also ensure compliance. Both parties should have their lawyer review the contract before signing to make sure all terms are clear and enforceable.

Disputes Over Ownership

Ownership disputes can arise when consigned goods are not properly identified or documented. Without clear evidence of ownership, the consignee or third parties can claim the goods. This can get especially messy if the consignee goes bankrupt and creditors try to seize the goods as part of the consignee’s assets.

For example, if a consignee mixes consigned goods with their own inventory without keeping records, the consignor may struggle to prove ownership. A consignor who put high value items into a store without documentation could struggle to get them back if the store claims they were their own. If a consignee sells consigned goods at a discount or claims ownership, the consignor may not get fair payment.

To avoid this, the agreement should require detailed inventory records, descriptions, serial numbers and photos of the consigned items. Consignors should mark their goods and do periodic audits to verify inventory. Having the consignee sign a receipt for each item and digital tracking systems can also prevent disputes. Legal provisions should state that the consignor retains ownership of the goods until they are sold and the consignee can’t use them as collateral for debts.

Failure to Define Liability for Damaged or Lost Goods

Another common dispute arises when consigned goods are damaged, lost or stolen while in the consignee’s possession. Without a clear liability clause, who bears the loss can lead to legal battles. If the consignee doesn’t take proper security measures, the consignor may suffer financial loss without recourse.

For example, a consignor sends an antique painting to a gallery but due to poor storage, the artwork is ruined by moisture. The gallery says they are not responsible for damages while the consignor demands payment. Without a clear liability clause, both parties may end up in court arguing over responsibility.

A good agreement should clearly outline who is responsible for the consigned goods. It should include provisions requiring the consignee to maintain proper storage conditions, security measures and insurance coverage. Clearly stating that the consignee is liable for damages caused by negligence ensures both parties understand their responsibilities. The contract should also require the consignee to report damages immediately and specify how compensation will be determined. Having the consignee carry insurance that covers consigned goods and listing the consignor as a beneficiary can also protect against financial loss.

Disputes Over Sales Proceeds

Conflicts can arise when the consignee doesn’t account for sales proceeds properly, either by underreporting sales, withholding payment or charging unexpected fees. The consignor relies on the consignee to report sales fairly and pay the correct amount due. When discrepancies happen, disputes can escalate quickly.

For example, a consignee sells a designer handbag on consignment and deducts extra handling and marketing fees not discussed. The consignor gets less than expected and disputes the deductions. In another scenario, the consignee doesn’t record all sales correctly and the consignor suspects foul play.

To avoid these conflicts, the agreement should clearly state commission rates, allowable fees and how proceeds will be split. A provision requiring regular sales reports and access to financial records can also help transparency. Both parties should agree on an approved method of tracking sales, such as a shared accounting system or automated reports. Requiring periodic financial reconciliations and using third-party auditing services can also prevent discrepancies. Having a protocol for disputes, such as mediation or arbitration, can resolve issues without litigation.

Early Termination and Breach of Contract

If either party wants to end the agreement before its term, disputes may arise over outstanding obligations, unsold goods and financial responsibilities. Without termination clauses, both parties can be left uncertain of their rights and significant conflicts can occur if one party doesn’t comply with the agreement.

For example, a consignor decides to pull out unsold merchandise before the agreement ends but the consignee refuses, citing an exclusive sales period. This leads to a legal dispute over contract interpretation. In another scenario, a consignee decides to stop selling the consignor’s goods suddenly and the consignor has to recover their inventory and unpaid funds.

A well-structured agreement should state conditions for early termination, including notice periods, return procedures and financial settlements. If there’s an exclusivity period, it should have an end date and a process for retrieving unsold goods. Having a dispute resolution process, such as mediation or arbitration, can also prevent costly litigation. And the agreement should have penalties for breach of contract so both parties take their obligations seriously.

By writing a consignment agreement with clear terms and conditions, consignors and consignees can minimize the chance of legal disputes and have a peaceful business relationship. A well-drafted contract not only gives legal protection but also builds trust and transparency between both parties to a successful consignment. Taking the time to spell out expectations, responsibilities and dispute resolution can save time and money in the long run. Get legal help when drafting the agreement to ensure compliance with laws and prevent misinterpretation or exploitation.

Related Documents
Download Free Template

Get started with Upsign today!

Easily send, sign and track your documents

Try For Free!
No credit card required